Archive for Minions of the Watch An Iced Earth forum for the fans!
 


       Minions of the Watch Forum Index -> The Music
The Sexiest Metalhead

Iced Earth vs. Arena

This is were you can compare songs, albums, members, ect...

I'll start.

Watching Over Me vs. The Pierced Spirit

Then, someone answers it. Then creates their own. It's quite simple really.
paranoidmexican

Watching Over me vs A question of Heaven
The Sexiest Metalhead

A Question of Heaven. It's just better all around.

(By the way, it dosen't need to be associated with the post before your own.)

(Album battle) Night of the Stormrider vs. The Dark Saga
paranoidmexican

Night of the Stormrider vs SWTWC
Dante

Night of the Stormrider alot of good songs... (all of them)

Song Battle: Dante's Inferno Vs The Gettysburg Trilogy
paranoidmexican

gettysburg trilogy hands down

brent smedley vs richard christy
Dante

Brent Smedley

Tim Owens vs Matt Barlow
The Sexiest Metalhead

I don't even have to think about that. Barlow.

(Songs) Iced Earth (original) vs. Iced Earth (Days of Purgatory)
The Wicked One

Days of Purgatory

Travel In Stygian (studio DOP) or Travel in Stygian (Live AIA)
paranoidmexican

the live in athens version hands down

travel in stygian AiA vs slave to the dark
Stormrider

Slave to the dark, if you mean studio version if you mean AiA version than Stygian.

Angels Holocaust (Stormrider Version) vs. Angels Holocaust (Days Of Purgatory Version)
The Wicked One

Days of Purgatory version.

Stormrider or God of Thunder?
Black_Sheep

Stormrider since the other is just a cover track. Stormrider also has some really kick ass riffs Smile

Burning Times or Framing Armageddon?
The Wicked One

Framing Armageddon.
Though Burning Times is really high on the list, FA is thrashier.

Dracula or Frankenstein
Set Abominae

The Wicked One wrote:
Framing Armageddon.
Though Burning Times is really high on the list, FA is thrashier.

Dracula or Frankenstein


Tough decision, but I'll go with the more epic.

Dracula or Desert Rain
Dante

Quote:
Tough decision, but I'll go with the more epic.

Dracula or Desert Rain

Dracula!!!


Dracula vs Damien
The Sexiest Metalhead

... I'll say Dracula. I love it.

Stand Alone vs. Violate
The Wicked One

Violate

Violate Vs Disciples of the Lie?
Set Abominae

The Wicked One wrote:
Violate

Violate Vs Disciples of the Lie?


Oh damn, another hard one....

Violate or When Stars Collide?
Sandra - Dark Saga -

Violate.

Travel in Stygian (Alive in Athens) or Dante's Inferno (Alive in Athens)
The Sexiest Metalhead

Sandra - Dark Saga - wrote:
Violate.

Travel in Stygian (Alive in Athens) or Dante's Inferno (Alive in Athens)


Dante's Inferno is a better song overall no matter what version.

A Charge to Keep vs. Order of the Rose
Sandra - Dark Saga -

Order of the Rose.

Travel in Stygian (AIA) or My Own Savior?
Dante

Sandra - Dark Saga - wrote:
Order of the Rose.

Travel in Stygian (AIA) or My Own Savior?


Travel in Stygian

The Path i Choose (J. Greely) vs The Path i Choose (M. Barlow)
The Sexiest Metalhead

I believe Matt is a better vocalist for the song, so Matt's version.

Cast in Stone vs. Mystical End
Dante

Mystical End...

Domino Decree vs Damien
The Sexiest Metalhead

Damien, even though the Domino Decree is great.

Wolf vs. Dragon's Child
Black_Sheep

Wolf

When The Night Falls vs Last December
Dante

When the Night Falls, it sounds so cool with the LOOK in the beginning.

Burnt Offerings vs Burning Times
Stormrider

Burnt Offerings

Original Falling Angel Cover to Iced Earth or Re release cover
The Wicked One

falling angel

burnt offerings original cover or reissue's?
The Sexiest Metalhead

I like the re-issues better...

Burning Oasis vs. Diary
Black_Sheep

Diary

Travel In Stygian VS The Clouding
The Sexiest Metalhead

Travel In Stygian, I was never a big fan of the Clouding...

Damien vs. Dante's Inferno
Dante

Dante's Inferno but it's close...

Dracula (Ripper) vs. Dracula (M.Barlow)
The Sexiest Metalhead

Barlow of course...  Laughing .

Hallowed Be Thy name vs. Dead Babies

Battle of covers.
Dante

Hallowed Be Thy Name of course, it's the best metal song ever.

The Last Laugh vs. Violate
The Sexiest Metalhead

Violate, that was a tough one. And I'm not being sarcastic.

1776 vs. Solitude (DOP)
Voice of Dissent

YES!!!! I'm SO GLAD I GOT THIS ONE!!!


1776, it is one of my favorite songs of all time.

Cover battle again...

God of Thunder vs. The Number of the Beast




btw... story about 1776... me, Adam (paranoidmexican), and our token black guy where in an assembly at school and I was playing Pokemon on my phone (because I'm awesome like that) and I let my token black friend play. Well while I was playing the game very discreetly (since phones arn't allowed in our school), our friend wasn't. After a couple minutes our bitch principle came over and took up my phone from my friend. Damn... life sucks... so after we spent a few minutes in scorn and contempt i remembered that (1.) it is only possible to exit the game if you go through a specific button process, (2.) my ringer was still on, and (3.) you can't answer phone calls while the game is running, but you can see and hear that you are getting them. So as you might imagine I told my black friend to take out his phone and we called my phone (the phone was kind of new at the time so I didn't have his number programed yet) and in the middle of the assembly starts playing 1776 at full volume. Ms. Bitch totally panicked and sat there for a couple seconds tryingt to first get my phone out of her purse in order to silence it and then spending a few more seconds failing miserably. Then after we had hung up and waited about 15 minutes we wen't one more time and this time the speaker stopped what he was saying and said "Ms. Meador!?!?!?" (Ms. Bitch's nickname). We tried again but we later found out she took it to her office and left it in there.
Dante

God of Thunder...
Actually i think that the original version of Number of the Beast is better, but Schaffers bad-as vocals nails that song!!!

Album:

Something Wicked This Way Comes vs. Horror Show
The Wicked One

as much as i love horror show the something wicked trilogy creates the gap.

Dark Saga or NOTSTR?
Set Abominae

The Wicked One wrote:
Dark Saga or NOTSTR?


DAMN that's hard, but I'm gonna go with NOTSR.

IE or BO?
The Sexiest Metalhead

I'd have to go with Burnt Offerings.

The Glourious Burden vs. Framing Armageddon
The Wicked One

That one is easy for me. Framing Armageddon!

Ten Thousand Strong vs. Setian Massacre
Voice of Dissent

Tough one for me but probably ten thousand strong

sticking with Framing Armageddon...

what's your favorite "filler" song (not sure what else to call them)

Overture or Execution (my favorite "filler")
Set Abominae

Voice of Dissent wrote:
what's your favorite "filler" song (not sure what else to call them)

Overture or Execution (my favorite "filler")


Overture.

Execution or Cataclysm?
The Wicked One

Execution

Awakening or Overture?
Dante

Overture.

Execution vs. Motivation of Man
The Wicked One

Motivation of Man


Invasion or Cataclysm
Tainted Innocence

prophecy VS. the coming curse?
Dante

The Coming Curse

Violate vs. My Own Savior?

That haven't been before right?
Aggelos Poneros

hm...  Violate

When The Night Falls vs. Nightmares?
The Wicked One

when the night falls, one of my favorites.

Winter Nights or Disciples of the Lie?
The Sexiest Metalhead

I'm going to go with winter Nights

Nightmares vs. Pure Evil
Dante

Pure Evil, i never really liked Nightmares.

Travel in Stygian vs. Desert Rain
Aggelos Poneros

Desert Rain

I Died For You vs A Question Of Heaven
The Wicked One

A Question of Heaven

Slave to The Dark vs  Dark Saga (song of course)
The Sexiest Metalhead

Slave to the Dark

The Hunter vs. Stormrider
Dante

Stormrider

The Coming Curse vs. Travel in Stygian
The Sexiest Metalhead

I'm goingt to have to go with the Coming Curse...

Jack vs. Damien
Dante

hmm those are two totally different songs... But i have to go with Damien

Greenface (America) vs. Waterloo (Europe)
Set Abominae

Dante wrote:
hmm those are two totally different songs... But i have to go with Damien

Greenface (America) vs. Waterloo (Europe)


GREEEEEEEEEEEEEEENFAAAAAAACE!!!

Iced Earth [song] vs Diary
The Sexiest Metalhead

Diary, love that song.

When the Eagle Cries vs. Watching over Me
Black_Sheep

Watching Over Me. It's a really great song.
-----

Attila vs Stand Alone
The Sexiest Metalhead

Stand Alone, my favorite Iced Earth song.

Red Baron/Blue Max vs. Dragon's Child
Aggelos Poneros

Dragon's Child

Last December vs. Creator Failure
Black_Sheep

Last December


Desert Rain VS Melancholy (Holy Martyr)
Set Abominae

Black_Sheep wrote:
Last December


Desert Rain VS Melancholy (Holy Martyr)


Desert Rain

Black Sabbath vs Transylvania?
Dante

Black Sabbath

Transylvania vs. 1776
paranoidmexican

Transylvania was an awesome cover

Transylvania VS Colors
Dante

Colors (live with Barlow is awesome!)

Life and Death vs. Curse The Sky
The Wicked One

Life and Death

Solitude or the Funeral?
Tainted Innocence

the funeral,
highway to hell (cover) VS. hallowed be thy name (cover)
The Wicked One

hallowed be thy name  FTMFW!!

Dead Babies or Screaming for Vengeance
Dante

Screaming for Vengeance

Diary vs. Dark Saga
Black_Sheep

Diary



Wolf VS Stormrider
Aggelos Poneros

Stormrider.


When The Stars Collide (Born Is He) vs. Ten Thousand Strong
Dante

Ten Thousand Strong

Wolf vs. The Hunter
The Sexiest Metalhead

Wolf, one of my favorite Iced Earth tracks.

The Domino Decree vs. Reaping Stone
Black_Sheep

The Domino Decree


Angels Holocaust VS The Coming Curse
The Wicked One

The Coming Curse

Angels Holocaust vs Burnt Offerings (song)
The Sexiest Metalhead

Angels Holocaust

The Pierced Spirit vs. Reaching the End
Dante

Reaching the End

Albums:
[Iced Earth, Night of the Stormrider, Burnt Offerings, Dark Saga] vs. [SWTWC, Horror Show, The Glorious Burden, Framing Armageddon]
The Sexiest Metalhead

That's tough, really tough. I like the first 4, but SWTWC and Horror Show are my two favorite ablums, but the Glourious Burden was a letdown. I'll go with the first 4, just for the fact TGB didn't live up to my standards.

Iced Earth (song) vs. (Burnt Offerings (song)
Dante

Hmm that to is a tough one...
But i think i have to go with Iced Earth.

Burnt Offerings vs. My Own Savior
The Wicked One

Burnt Offerings

Blessed Are You or Last December
Black_Sheep

Last December


Motivation Of Man VS Ghost Of Freedom
The Sexiest Metalhead

Ghost of Freedom, love that song.

Ghost of Freedom vs. When the Eagle Cries
The Wicked One

Ghost of Freedom

When The Eagle Cries vs When The Eagle Cries(unplugged)
Voice of Dissent

Unplugged

Valley Forge vs. Ghost of Freedom
The Sexiest Metalhead

Ghoast of Freedom

Valley Forge vs. Attila
Dante

Attila

Gettysburg Trilogy vs. Something Wicked Trilogy (If this has been before then let someone else answer)
The Wicked One

Something Wicked but the orchestra for Gettysburg was amazing.

How about this
The Suffering vs The Something Wicked Trilogy
Tainted Innocence

damn,
the suffering is a bad ass song but its kinda repetitive...
but the somehting wicked trio is something that jus cant be beat.
Dante

Yep that's a hard one...
But i think as said before that the suffering is kind of repetitive. So i go with Something Wicked Trilogy.

Stormrider (with intro) vs. Stormrider (without intro)
(Intro: As i travel trough the...)
The Wicked One

without, i like how the intro was ending for Angels Holocaust. very fitting.

The Coming Curse with or without the piano intro?
Tainted Innocence

deffinetly with,
i like the alive in athens one though (it was shorter)
uhmmmm....
wathing over me VS. i died for you.
Aggelos Poneros

I Died For You, I love that song...

Burnt Offerings vs. Dark Saga (songs)
Dante

Burnt Offerings

Melancholy vs. Consequences
Aggelos Poneros

Melancholy

Damien vs. Dracula
Dante

I had that in post 2 Smile

But i think I'll go with Dracula if it's Live and Damien if it's on the Horror Show.

The intro of Damien vs. The intro of Angels Holocaust
Both using Gregorian chant doesn't they?

       Minions of the Watch Forum Index -> The Music Page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next
Page 1 of 7
Create your own free forum | Buy a domain to use with your forum