TheVileMessiah
|
Preferred Singer [Not Including Barlow]In order for me it's
1. Greely
2. Ripper
3. Adam
|
The Wicked One
|
Can't decide. After all Greely had a badass album and is working on another while Ripper has so much more material.
|
Kanadwen
|
Ripper hands down. Not a lot of songs, even of Barlow's, can top the Gettysburg trilogy.
|
Black_Sheep
|
Tim is the best! Matt is my overall favorite.
Adam and Greely suck. They are nothing compared to Matt and Tim.
|
The Wicked One
|
I wouldn't say they suck. Especially Greely.
of course it is too be said that Gene Adam didn't have as much note hitting talent in comparison to the others but i'll say it once and always, Gene gave a chuck billy vibe and chuck billy fucking rules.
|
Kanadwen
|
Greely is good. Adams on the other hand, I could never ever really get into. I hate his screams! I cringe every time I hear Iced Earth (song title) with him singing, it's God awful! I like him in Colors tho...
|
paranoidmexican
|
to be honest, i like all the singers alot
|
Dante
|
Rippers Gettysburg is the best frikkin trilogy in the world! (hmm... Manfredis
Alexander trilogy is also in the top!)
Shouldn't this be in Past and Present members?
|
abominae1
|
I like Ripper better than Greely or Adams. Ripper's perfomance on Gettysburg is excellent.
|
Tainted Innocence
|
i think that greely and adam had no talent...
and i think i can actually sing better then them.
|
Proll
|
Ripper for vocal skill
As for Iced Earth eras, Greely hands down.
|
The Sexiest Metalhead
|
Gene Adam = Bad... not a good singer what so ever.
John Greely = Not as bad... but nothing special.
Tim Owens = The best of the three... by far. Eventhough his live performance can be touchy at times, he's an amazing studio performer.
Tim's the best.
Greely is ok.
Gene is just bad.
|
the one true seeker
|
Got to go the Ripper. Of course Barlow is preferred. 
|
Zook
|
Gene Adam is terrible and whoever told him he could/should sing needs to be kicked in the shin.
John Greely isn't that bad actually, but has his moments of fail. What the fuck is "Splatch", Greely?! How did Schaffer not catch this?
Timporary Owens is pretty awesome, but lacks the lower range. He was badass on Framing Armageddon too.
Winner = Ripper
|
KupoBarlow
|
| Tainted Innocence wrote: | i think that greely and adam had no talent...
and i think i can actually sing better then them. |
I think Greely is a good vocalist, but compared with Matt or Tim, his performances aren't good at all, cause' we heard the GREAT version, the kick ass versions, you know....BTW, Gene Adams SUCKS HARDLY!!
|
|
|
